Islamic Finance and Impact Investing

IS THERE A HALAL INDEX FUND?

Yes, there are many options these days for those looking for halal index funds.

Index funds have long been known as one of the best and easiest ways to invest your money. The increase in the availability of halal index funds, that is funds that comply with Islamic Sharia rules, means that there is an even greater opportunity to maximise your investments without breaching Islamic finance principles.

Halal index funds enable investors to invest in a wider selection of stocks all within one fund.

WHAT ARE INDEX FUNDS?

An index fund is essentially a fund that follows what is known as a benchmark index, for example, Nasdaq 100, FTSE 100, and the S&P 500. Index funds are a portfolio of stocks and bonds.

Index funds are generally regarded as a passive form of investing. What this means is that investors who invest in index funds do not have to actively manage their investments.

The index fund will aim to mirror the index they track, they do not need to be actively and constantly managed.

Exchanged traded funds (ETFs) are those funds that are traded on exchanges and usually ETFs will track a specific index. EFTs offer investors a basket or bundle of assets that can be traded. The result is that the portfolio is diversified and the risk is deemed to be low, especially in times of economic growth.

Index funds are popular with all kinds of investors from angel investors, stock investors, new investors, and those looking for responsible investment options.

Difference Between Mutual Funds And Index Funds

The main difference between mutual funds and index funds is that mutual funds need a great deal more active management by fund managers. These fund managers actively choose the investments and manage the mutual fund and this leads to increased management fees and costs.

Before making any kind of investment in index funds you should make some inquiries about the fund, read online information from the relevant website and try and look into the methodology the fund uses (this includes yield, capitalisation, and price).

HOW DO INDEX FUNDS WORK?

Index funds work by investors investing their money in to an index fund that has been created. The money is then used to invest into the companies that comprise the particular index fund chosen. This means investors are able to diversify their portfolios and invest in companies they want to.

For example, if an investor invests money in the S&P 500. This index fund essentially tracks the performance of 500 of the largest companies in the USA. The S&P 500 is one of the largest and most popular index funds on the market.

Investing in companies via index funds means that investors' money is linked to, and tied up with, the performance of the companies within the fund. Many of these index funds have a very wide range of companies within the fund.

INDEX FUNDS WHAT ARE THE RISKS?

As many of the most popular index funds are diverse, this means they are less risky for investors. The reason the risk is lowered with index funds is that there are usually many companies within the fund, so all the investment is not tied up with the performance of one company.

Index funds are known for offering what is considered to be a broad market exposure for investors, with very low operating costs and risk. Index funds are popular with people who want to use the fund as a pension and plan for retirement.

Index funds are normally managed by a fund manager whose employment is based on ensuring that the fund is managed and tracked properly.

Sharia Principles Relating To Index Funds

The Sharia rules that relate to investment funds are the same rules that apply across all financial transactions.The main principles of Islamic finance that should always be considered when looking for halal index funds to invest in include the following:

• There should be no element of interest (riba)
• The investments should be ethical and should enhance communities and society in keeping with the social justice element of Islamic finance
• There should be no element of speculation or gambling (maisir)
• Both parties in the transaction should share the risks and profits
• There should be no transactions involving uncertainty (gharar)
• There must be asset backing - this means that every financial investment and transaction must relate to a tangible asset
• The industries, business, and companies within the fund should not be deemed to be impermissible in Islam

WHAT INDEX FUND IS HALAL?

The aim of halal index funds is to create long term appreciation of the investment funds via a diversified portfolio. Revenue is generated if the portfolio increases in value.

This portfolio is securities and investments are compliant with Islamic finance investment principles as laid down by Sharia laws.

Two of the largest index funds are the HSBC Islamic Global Equity Index Fund (halal) and the Vanguard FTSE 100 Index Fund. In the United States, the Dow Jones Industrial Average is one of the most popular funds to invest in. However, there are other index funds that meet the Sharia principles of halal investment. The numbers in the name often refer to the number of companies included within the index. For example, the FTSE 100 includes the largest 250 companies that are currently listed on the London Stock Exchange.

Before investing, always make sure you have done your due diligence and that the index fund you are investing in has been certified as compliant with Sharia rules.

For Muslims, the main incentive for investing in halal index funds is that they comply with Islamic finance rules and regulations. Any stock or bond within a halal index fund needs to be compliant with Sharia rules relating to investing.

ADVANTAGES OF INVESTING IN HALAL INDEX FUNDS - IS INVESTING IN A FUND HALAL?

One of the main advantages for any individual investing in a halal index fund or product is knowing that you will be investing your money in funds that comply with Sharia principles. Halal index funds also take care to ensure that the money is not invested in industries prohibited by Islamic finance principles (such as the gambling, alcohol, and porn industries).

For investors who want to invest in an ethical way that does not adversely impact society, then halal index funds offer the opportunity to do that. The relevance of halal index funds has grown significantly in recent years with the increase in demand for Sharia compliant and ethical investment options.

There is a great deal of global movement towards more responsible investing and halal index funds meet the criteria for ethical investing.

In the United Kingdom, index funds are regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

Considerations For Investors Wanting To Invest In Halal Index Funds

Investment in any kind of fund comes with its own risks. You should always seek to do as much research as possible before you invest.

Some of the key risks relating to halal index funds include:

• Risk of the investment value going down
• Exchange rate risks - if the economy and the markets are volatile then the exchange rates could fluctuate and affect your investment gains
• Tracking risks - whilst index funds will track the index, you should expect to see occasional differences in the gains
• Operational risks - as with any fund, halal index funds could be subject to operational and compliance risks which could affect any profit or return generated

LOOKING FOR THE RIGHT HALAL INDEX FUND - IS THE S&P FUND HALAL?

In addition to the points raised above, if you want to invest in a halal index fund then you should look specifically for:

• Confirmation/documentation that the index fund has been certified as being compliant with Sharia rules
• The scope for diversification - the greater the diversification the lower your overall risk
• Fund fees - check what fees your investment will incur
• Foreign companies - looking at companies abroad is a great way of diversifying your portfolio and finding halal investment funds
• Minimum investment levels - check to see if there is a minimum investment level required for the fund you are interested in. Many halal index funds are accessible and have reasonable charges for every level of investor
• Information - check what information is available on the index funds you are interested in. If you have any questions find an expert who can help you with your queries

As halal index funds grow in popularity across the globe it is important to find the fund that works best for you. Currently, Apple is deemed to be one of the largest holdings in the S&P Shariah Index.

SAVING VERSUS INVESTING IN INDEX FUNDS?

Whilst is it always a good idea to have savings, if you are comfortable with taking small risks and want to diversify your investment portfolio, then halal index funds are the way forward.

If you are risk averse and do not want to deal with any market fluctuations, then it is probably best for you to maximise your savings. However, in the current economy savings are not the best way to use your money. Also, for Muslims who are not permitted to make use of high interest savings accounts, looking into index funds is a good way of earning revenue from the money they have.

Halal index funds are a great way for beginners to invest in the stock market. Index funds enable investors to own a share in a company for relatively low cost.

The company that manages the fund will do all the running around and hard work so you do not have to.

Cryptocurrency is a form of virtual currency that is based on blockchain technology. Cryptocurrency is a digital asset, and the vast majority of cryptocurrencies are based on decentralised networks. This means that the currencies exist outside of centralised structures such as governments and banks.

The blockchain technology makes it virtually impossible for the system to be duplicated, hacked, or cheated, and acts as a centralised ledger of the currency. Digital assets such as bitcoin are still relatively new assets on the global financial markets. Many Muslims are seeking clarity as to whether cryptocurrency is deemed to be halal and Sharia compliant from an Islamic perspective.

The mathematical value calculation of cryptocurrency coins is based on the algorithm of the blockchain itself. Blockchain technology is seen as being an efficient, safe, and undeletable system. This lends credence and transparency to the cryptocurrency market. The question of whether bitcoin and other digital assets are halal is one that has been discussed and debated in recent years.

The former Sharia adviser to Blossom Finance, Mufti Muhammad Abu-Bakr, compiled a report in 2019 that stated that cryptocurrencies, including bitcoin, should be deemed to be halal and permissible under Sharia law. Mufti Abu-Bakr's decision was made on the basis that all traditional (and permissible) currencies tend to have a speculative element and cryptocurrencies should therefore be permissible in Islam. Since his report, Muslims have considered investing, trading, and exploring bitcoin as a new way of transacting with others.

Scholars

In 2018, scholars from the Sharia Review Bureau in Bahrain stated that investment in cryptocurrency and coins such as Ethereum and bitcoins were permissible under Sharia law and halal. Their view was that bitcoin could be considered property (maal), and did not contain any form of interest.

Similarly, the Fiqh Council of North America has unanimously decided that bitcoin is permissible. Furthermore, the Sharia Advisory Council branch of Malaysia's security commission has advised that trading and investing in cryptocurrencies is permissible. This means that digital currencies can also be used to make zakat payments.

The Shacklewell Lane Mosque in London was one of the first mosques in the UK to accept cryptocurrency donations from Muslims. Most scholarly interpretations of digital currencies in the last few years have determined that cryptocurrencies are in fact halal.

Whilst many scholars have researched and reviewed the digital currency market, it is important for investors to undertake their own research before investing. In order to consider whether bitcoin is halal, we need to delve into the history of money from an Islamic perspective so that we can revisit the centuries-old Sharia rules relating to finance and investment.

This article will examine the historical perspective and apply the current interpretations in relation to bitcoin.

How Cryptocurrency Works

All cryptocurrency coins are virtual coins that exist in the crypto market, they do not have any physical form. The actual proof of legal ownership of the digital money is recorded on blockchain technology. The blockchain acts as a public record that records the digital growth of the coin, and the value of each coin.

Cryptocurrency works by recording transactions on a ledger and creating blocks. The ledger is available 24/7 and cannot be changed or overwritten. It is virtually impossible to counterfeit crypto, and all the computers that store blockchain technology have to 'agree' to comply with the accurate version of the ledger. When anyone purchases digital currency such as bitcoin they then own a private key that provides them with a code that authorises cryptocurrency transactions.

In the UK there are now cryptocurrency ATMs in London and further down south in areas including Plymouth and Penzance.

What Is A Bitcoin

Bitcoin was first created as a digital currency after the 2008 global market crash caused by the banks. At the time, there was a lot of interest in and demand for a decentralised system of money that was not controlled by banks and governments.Key features of bitcoin include the following:

• It is decentralised - there is no central power controlling it, instead is it based on sophisticated computer programmes
• It is transparent - everyone on the ledger can see the transactions undertaken
• It is non-repudiable - a buyer cannot claim they did not receive their coin if they did receive it
• It is easy and simple to set up
• The value of bitcoin is based on demand
• It is a trustable coin
• Anonymity - all bitcoin transactions are stored on a public ledger so there is very little secrecy

Bitcoins are traded through bitcoin exchanges. To send bitcoin to another investor you will need to use your private key to effectively 'sign off' on the transaction. Once the transaction is verified it cannot be reversed or revoked.

Islamic Perspective On The History Of Money

The history of money from an Islamic perspective can be traced back to the beginning of Islam. Islamically and under Sharia law, money is used for exchange rather than speculation or exploitation. This is one of the reasons that riba (interest) is strictly forbidden in Islam as it is seen as making a profit on money. The Islamic perspective of money and business rests on principles of social justice and non-exploitation.

Sharia laws relating to money state that to be used as a means of exchange the money should be safe, stable, and effective. The reason some Muslims are conflicted about the legitimacy of bitcoin and whether it is Sharia law compliant is that when the Quran was written there will obviously have been no mention of digital currencies as technology was not in the advanced stage it is today. This has meant that the permissibility of cryptocurrency has been open to judgement and interpretation by scholars.

Bitcoin And Islamic Finance

The question about whether bitcoin is deemed to be halal Islamically has been raised again and again as Muslims across the globe consider whether to invest in cryptocurrency. Cryptocurrency is based on supply and demand in the way normal currencies often are, and the coins themselves hold value based on the market.

Bitcoin heralded the birth of the free, transparent, global financial market. It is not surprising, therefore, that Muslims began to interact with this market. Islamic finance rules provide boundaries and regulations relating to financial dealings. Whilst cryptocurrency is still a prominent area of news and research for Islamic finance scholars and experts, what is clear is that the majority of scholars and Imams have interpreted that cryptocurrencies do not breach any of the Sharia rules relating to Islamic finance.

Bitcoin And Sharia Finance Rules - Key Principles

The main features of Islamic finance that need to be considered when it comes to bitcoin are:

1. Interest (riba) - interest is prohibited in Islam
2. Speculation (maysir) - speculative investment is deemed to be akin to gambling and is not permissible
3. Profit-loss sharing - parties to a transaction must share the risks and rewards according to Islamic finance
4. No excessive risk (gharar) - Islamic finance dictates that transactions that are uncertain or carry excessive risk are not permissible.
5. Application of trade and commerce (al bai')

Examining the Islamic finance principles mentioned above, it is clear that there is room for digital assets within an Islamic finance portfolio. Bitcoin does not have an interest element, nor does it provide one party with excessive profits or losses, or excessive risk.

As the world of cryptocurrencies continues to evolve, so does the demand for Sharia compliant coins. Recently, the Caizcoin was developed in Germany and marketed as the first fully Sharia compliant digital coin. It is likely that there will be further developments of digital currencies that meet all the requirements of Islamic finance principles.

Interpretations

Although already deemed Sharia compliant by Imams and scholars throughout the world, the Islamic cryptocurrency finance market is evolving to ensure that Muslims are catered for when it comes to investing in cryptocurrency. In January 2021, CoinMENA, the Middle Eastern digital assets exchange was given the go ahead from the Central Bank of Bahrain to become a certified sharia compliant exchange.

Muslims are becoming increasingly involved with the emerging digital currency fintech market, especially younger Muslims who are moving away from traditional forms of investment and entrepreneurship.

Conclusion

Discussions around bitcoin and other forms of cryptocurrency will continue in the years to come. Although many Muslim scholars have determined that investing in cryptocurrencies is halal, there will be some Muslims who will want to adopt a wait and see policy. As long as the bitcoin investment does not include haram activities then bitcoin itself does not contravene any Islamic finance principles that regulate investment, money management and currencies. What seems clear is that conceptually, bitcoin and cryptocurrency as a whole do not appear to be impermissible according to Sharia law rules. The growth of the Islamic cryptocurrency exchanges and coins does mean that there is more clarity and regulation than ever before for Muslims looking to invest in digital currencies.

WHAT IS STUDENT FINANCE?

Student finance in the United Kingdom is funding that is available for students to access to help cover the cost of their further education. The organisation that is responsible for administering and calculating the extent of the student loan payment is the Student Loans Company.

The Student Loan Company was founded in 1990 and was created to provide students with financial support towards their further education. Currently, student finance can be applied for by students to pay for their university tuition fees and living costs while they are studying.

Every student in the UK is entitled to a loan to cover tuition fees. Tuition fees tend to be decided by the universities and the Student Loan Company will make the payment direct to the educational establishment. Currently, in the UK those studying full time can receive up to £9250 per annum towards tuition fees, and additional funds for living costs known as the maintenance grant.

Repayment Of Student Loans

Student loans need to be repaid in full whether or not the student completes the university course or not. The amount you repay depends on your income and is deducted from your salary in the same way National Insurance and tax are deducted.

You become eligible to repay your student loan (with interest) once your income exceeds a certain threshold. In the UK this threshold is currently around £25,000 per year. Repayments are calculated at 9% on sums over the threshold, and the repayment is subject to interest charges.

WHAT IS MEANT BY HALAL STUDENT FINANCE?

Halal student finance in the UK refers to those financial arrangements that students can access to advance and fund their further education. Any halal student finance or loan needs to be compliant with Islamic finance and Sharia principles relating to money.

Specifically, Islamic student finance means that there should be no interest payable or charged on the loan or fees associated with education. Islamically, interest is considered to be haram and should be avoided at all costs.

The concept of halal student finance is structured to ensure that is adheres to Sharia rules and that the financing of education is compliant with ethical and religious rules. The main principle to be aware of is that the arrangement must not involve any form of interest and the transaction should be non-exploitative and transparent.

For many Muslim students, not having access to halal student finance via the Student Loans Company means they do not pursue their further education goals. The main reason for this is that the current student loan system is based on interest repayments.

Student Loans And Interest

Interest on student loans is an integral part of the system that funds further education. This is generally how student loans operate:

1. Student applies for university, is accepted on to the course, and then makes a student loan application.
2. There are two main elements to the student loan:
3. Tuition fees that cover the cost of the course tuition
4. Maintenance loan that is aimed to help with the living costs including rent, and books.
5. To be eligible for a student loan you need to be resident in the UK and have been accepted on to a course.
6. Repayment of the student loan includes interest and the rate of interest depends on factors such as when you took out the student loan. Repayment only begins post graduation and once you earn over a certain threshold.
7. Interest on the loan accrues from when you receive the funds until the full loan is repaid.

In addition to student loans, there are also scholarships and bursaries available for some students. Postgraduates can also apply for student finance but whether they receive it or not depends on their circumstances.

Before considering any form of loan it is important for you to gather all the information relating to the loan and how it impacts you now and in the future. Whilst many see student loans as an investment in the future, there have been concerns raised about the inability of Muslim students to access student finance.

WHY IS IT IMPORTANT FOR MUSLIM STUDENTS TO ACCESS HALAL STUDENT FINANCE?

Muslims want to be able enter and partake in higher education without breaching Sharia rules. Currently, as the UK student loan system is interest-based, this precludes many Muslims from being able to access the funding they need to study further.

Islam prohibits interest and at the moment there is no interest-free funding option for students. There is a need for student finance based on Islamic finance principles that form part of the student loan scheme in the UK.

It's not only the interest element that is a problem for Muslim students. The existing student loan system is subject to change and this could fall into the remit of gharar (uncertainty) in Islam which is discouraged.

Without doubt, a halal payment system for Muslim students will facilitate greater inclusion in the education system.

Islamic Finance And Student Loans

Some key features of a halal student loan include the following:

• interest free loans: it goes without saying that any form of student finance must ensure there is no interest being charged or paid in order for the loan to be deemed halal. Instead, what is expected to happen is that the lending institution or bank charges fees or alternative structures to fund the transaction.
• Ethical: halal student finance cannot be unethical. This goes against the basic Islamic finance principles. Any halal form of finance or funding needs to steer clear of haram industries such as gambling, porn, and alcohol.
• Transparent: for a student loan arrangement to be compliant with Sharia rules, it must be transparent and clear. Both parties in the transaction should fully understand the terms which themselves should be clear and non-ambiguous.
• Risk and profit sharing: a key component of Islamic finance is that there is adequate profit and risk sharing between the parties. The student should not bare all the responsibility and risk in this kind of arrangement.

Consultation On Halal Student Finance

In 2014 the government launched a consultation relating to Islamic finance based student loans. What they found was that of the 20,000 respondents, over 90% stated that there was a demand for Sharia compliant student finance.

In March 2023 the government in the UK (having consulted on lifelong loan entitlement) confirmed that although a Sharia compliant student finance product was not available, it was committed to funding an alternative form of finance for students.

The government discussed several criteria that should be applied in a halal student finance system including:

• repayments should be easy to make
• any alternative system should be operated through the student loans company
• debt and repayment levels should be the same as they are for other students
• the service should be easy to use and transparent

Halal Student Finance And The Takaful System

At the time they were considering halal student finance options, the government concluded that a takaful system would be most appropriate. In Islam takaful refers to Islamic insurance and is based on cooperation and mutuality.

Takaful systems operate without insurance or gharar.

Unfortunately, no halal student finance option ever really emerged. Instead the government focused on other areas of student finance and simply concluded that they would continue to consider halal student loans.

Whilst government controlled and regulated student loans may not be available as yet, there are still halal finance options available. Some financial institutions are offering Sharia compliant loans that could be used for education.

Tips For Students Who Want Halal Student Finance

For students who are looking for halal student finance alternatives, here are some options you can consider:

• Research Islamic finance products and services
• Look into Islamic scholarships
• Speak with Islamic finance advisors
• Speak to your university finance team and ask them for details of hardship funds or grants
• Consider interest-free loans from family

None of the above are ideal for Muslim students but could provide alternative halal funding for further study.

The future of halal student finance is dependent on many factors including the demand, the economic landscape, and the continued growth of Islamic finance. The Islamic finance industry is innovative and dynamic and could partner up with educational establishments in the future.

Increased awareness and education about the need for halal student loans is also something that could potentially speed up the availability of halal loans. Muslim students need to stay informed and alert and always explore all the options available to them before deciding against pursuing further education.